Victory in Senate lawsuit vs. House on hold-up of HB 6058

On Thursday, the state Senate was victorious in their lawsuit against the House to compel the presentation of bills being held back from the governor – including HB 6058, which works to reduce skyrocketing out-of-pocket health insurance costs for educators and other public employees.

Court of Appeals Judge Sima Patel ruled in favor of Senate Majority Leader Winnie Brinks and the Michigan Senate in Michigan Senate v. Michigan House of Representatives. The lawsuit was brought forth by Leader Brinks after House Speaker Matt Hall failed to present nine bills that passed both chambers to Gov. Gretchen Whitmer.

Judge Patel’s ruling specifically cites the duty that the bills be presented to Gov. Whitmer at least 14 days before the bills would go into effect (meaning by March 19), saying: “Simply put, all bills passed by the Legislature must be presented to the Governor within time to allow 14 days for the Governor’s review prior to the first date that they could take effect – even those passed during a ‘lame duck’ session in an even year.

Senate Democrats celebrated the ruling. “This case was clear as day. The most solemn and fundamental duty we have as legislators is to uphold the Constitution, and I am grateful to Judge Patel for making that abundantly clear with her decision today,” Brinks said in a statement. “I hope that this serves as a signal to any legislator who attempts to skirt the rules: We will hold you accountable to doing right by the people of Michigan.  Let’s now put this to bed and move forward with the work of the people – they’re counting on us.”

Since the ruling stopped short of ordering the House to present the bills, the case is likely not finished – especially if Speaker Hall continues to hold these bills hostage.  Stay tuned for more details from MEA about any appeals and timelines.  In the meantime, continue to tell Speaker Matt Hall to uphold the Michigan Constitution — and this new court ruling — and send HB 6058 to Gov. Whitmer.

HB 6058 Home-Sidebar Legislation Newsroom

Releated

RSVP Now for Sept. 24 Education Budget Lobby Day

Plan now to join MEA and AFT Michigan for an education funding lobby day in Lansing next Wednesday, Sept. 24. With the budget deadline looming, we need union members and supporters in Lansing to tell lawmakers to fund our schools, including critical programs like free school meals and mental health supports. Our students deserve to […]

Educator joins ‘Art of Democracy’ exhibition

For MEA member Sarah Ellis, making art is essential to being alive and human — like breathing. “For as long as we’ve been able to recognize that humans have existed, we’ve found art alongside them,” she says. In a time of deep societal divisions, Ellis wants art to be a source of hope and empowerment […]